Life insurance is an important financial tool that provides peace of mind to individuals and their families. When someone takes out a life insurance policy, they usually name a beneficiary who will receive the payout when they pass away. However, disputes can arise when there is uncertainty about who should receive the benefits. In New Jersey, many of these disputes come down to one key factor—intent. The role of intent is crucial in life insurance beneficiary disputes because it often determines the outcome of the case. Understanding how intent plays a role in these disputes can help clarify the complexities involved and why having the right guidance is essential. At, Trief & Olk, we are here to guide you through the legal process and help you navigate the complexities of your case.
What is Intent in a Life Insurance Policy?
Intent refers to the true wishes and plans of the policyholder, also known as the insured, regarding who should receive the life insurance benefits after their death. When a policyholder names a beneficiary, it is their intention that this person, or sometimes a group of people, will receive the insurance payout. This can seem simple, but issues arise when intent is unclear or when there are questions about whether the policyholder’s intent changed over time. If there are conflicting claims or doubts about who the intended beneficiary was, the courts may have to step in to determine what the policyholder’s true wishes were.
Disputes over intent often occur when the policyholder changes their beneficiary designation. For example, they may have named a spouse as the beneficiary when they first bought the policy, but later went through a divorce and never updated the beneficiary designation. In other cases, the policyholder may have verbally expressed a desire to change the beneficiary but did not submit the necessary paperwork. These situations can lead to confusion and legal battles, with various parties arguing over what the policyholder truly intended.
Why Do Beneficiary Disputes Happen?
There are many reasons why disputes over life insurance beneficiaries happen in New Jersey. Sometimes the policyholder’s intent was never clear, or it changed but was never properly documented. In other cases, the policyholder may have been pressured or manipulated into making changes to their beneficiary designation. This can happen if someone takes advantage of an elderly or ill policyholder to have themselves named as the beneficiary. If the family of the deceased suspects that the policyholder was coerced or lacked the mental capacity to make such a decision, they may contest the beneficiary designation in court.
Another common reason for disputes is when there are competing claims to the life insurance benefits. For example, if the policyholder had multiple family members who believed they were the intended beneficiary, a dispute can arise. This is especially common in cases of blended families, where children from different marriages may have competing claims. Each party may argue that the policyholder intended for them to receive the benefits, and the courts must then determine what the policyholder truly intended.
The Importance of Clear Documentation
One of the most effective ways to avoid life insurance beneficiary disputes is by ensuring that the policyholder’s intentions are clearly documented. This means that any changes to the beneficiary designation should be made in writing and submitted to the life insurance company according to their procedures. Verbal promises or informal notes are generally not enough to prove intent in court. Clear, legally recognized documentation is essential in these cases.
In New Jersey, courts will usually look at the most recent beneficiary designation on file with the insurance company to determine who should receive the benefits. However, if there is evidence that this designation does not reflect the policyholder’s true intent, the courts may consider other factors, such as written statements or even the testimony of witnesses. This is why it is so important for policyholders to keep their beneficiary designations up to date and to ensure that any changes they wish to make are properly documented.
We contacted Trief & Olk to help us with a life insurance issue and Shelly Friedland was the attorney assigned to our case. Before Shelly took our case she explained to us that the likelihood of our success without going to court was possible but not likely. Unfortunately we did not get the outcome we had hoped for but it was our decision to not move forward and have our case litigated. Shelly is very knowledgeable and was very straight-forward in her assessment of our case as we moved forward. She was very patient and thorough in answering our questions. She always responded in a timely manner and listened to our concerns. We would certainly recommend Shelly and would use her firm again in the future.” - John Ramig If there is any possibility of winning your life insurance case – this is the place to do it for you. They are efficient, honest and will achieve the best possible outcome. Shelly Friedland worked on my case where a life insurance policy had lapsed and was even a few days beyond the grace period. Farmers had rejected my claim twice and was unwilling to take a second look. Shelly was able to get them to pay the entire claim without going to court, and the full amount was deposited in my account within a couple months. Highest recommendation.” - Kathleen Brown Trief & Olk is a superior law firm. Their attorneys and other legal professionals have a brilliant understanding of the law and the litigation process. They diligently perform their work in an efficient, strategic and cost-effective manner to ensure the best possible outcomes for their clients. - Christopher Hughes
The Role of the Courts in Determining Intent
When life insurance beneficiary disputes cannot be resolved among the parties involved, they often end up in court. In New Jersey, the court’s role is to determine what the policyholder’s intent was at the time of their death. This can be a complex process, as the courts must consider both the legal documentation and any additional evidence that might shed light on the policyholder’s wishes.
The court will look closely at the beneficiary designation on the life insurance policy. If there are no questions about the validity of this designation, the court will usually honor it. However, if there are claims that the designation was made under duress, or if there is evidence that the policyholder intended to make a change but did not complete the paperwork, the court may consider other factors. For example, the court might review letters, emails, or other documents where the policyholder expressed their wishes. The court may also listen to testimony from family members, friends, or legal representatives who had conversations with the policyholder about their intentions.
In some cases, the court may appoint a neutral third party, such as a legal guardian or trustee, to help oversee the distribution of the life insurance benefits. This is done to ensure that the benefits are distributed according to the policyholder’s true intent, especially in cases where there is uncertainty or conflicting claims.
20% The annual average number of life insurance claims denied. $50 Million The yearly average dollar amount of claims denied by life insurance companies. .2% The number of claims appealed annually by consumers.Life Insurance Denial Statistics
How Undue Influence Affects Beneficiary Disputes
One of the most challenging aspects of life insurance beneficiary disputes is when there are allegations of undue influence. Undue influence occurs when someone pressures or manipulates the policyholder into making decisions that they would not have made otherwise. This can happen if the policyholder is elderly, ill, or otherwise vulnerable and is taken advantage of by someone who wants to be named as the beneficiary. In these cases, the court will look closely at the circumstances under which the beneficiary designation was made to determine if the policyholder’s intent was compromised.
Proving undue influence can be difficult, but it is not impossible. Courts will look for signs that the policyholder was not acting freely and voluntarily when they made the beneficiary designation. This might include evidence that the policyholder was isolated from other family members, that they were dependent on the person who became the beneficiary, or that they were not fully aware of what they were signing. If undue influence is proven, the court may invalidate the beneficiary designation and award the life insurance benefits to another party.
How Changing Life Circumstances Affect Intent
As people’s lives change, so too do their intentions when it comes to their life insurance policies. Major life events, such as marriage, divorce, the birth of a child, or the death of a spouse, can all lead to changes in the policyholder’s intent regarding their beneficiaries. Unfortunately, many people forget to update their beneficiary designations after these events, leading to disputes after their death.
In New Jersey, divorce is a common factor in life insurance beneficiary disputes. Under state law, if a policyholder names their spouse as the beneficiary of their life insurance policy and they later divorce, the beneficiary designation is automatically revoked unless the policyholder takes steps to reaffirm their choice. This is intended to protect policyholders who may have forgotten to update their beneficiary designation after their divorce. However, if the policyholder still intended for their ex-spouse to receive the benefits, they must clearly document this intent in order for the designation to stand.
Settlements & Verdicts
The Value of Legal Assistance in Beneficiary Disputes
Life insurance beneficiary disputes can be emotionally charged and legally complex. When intent is unclear or there are competing claims to the benefits, the stakes can be high. This is why having legal assistance is crucial in these cases. A knowledgeable legal team can help gather evidence, navigate the court system, and advocate for the policyholder’s true intent to be honored.
At Trief & Olk, our team understands the challenges involved in life insurance beneficiary disputes and the importance of ensuring that the policyholder’s wishes are respected. If you are involved in a life insurance dispute in New Jersey and need guidance, our experienced team is here to help. Contact Trief & Olk today to learn more about how we can assist you with your case.