Disputes Over Insurance Proceeds Between Life Insurance Beneficiaries

Resolving Life Insurance Beneficiary Disputes in New York: A Legal Overview

Posted on by Trief & Olk
Life insurance can provide financial protection for families after the death of a loved one. It is meant to bring some peace of mind during a time of grief by ensuring that beneficiaries receive the money promised to them. However, disputes over life insurance beneficiary designations can arise, creating uncertainty and stress. When this happens, families may need to rely on legal guidance to resolve these issues.
In New York, the law offers specific ways to handle disputes over who is the rightful beneficiary of a life insurance policy. These disputes can occur for various reasons. Sometimes, the policyholder’s intentions may be unclear or someone may contest a change to the beneficiary list. Regardless of the reason, resolving these disputes requires careful review of legal documents, policies, and state law. Understanding how New York handles these disputes can help beneficiaries and family members prepare for challenges that may arise. Below, we will explore the common reasons for disputes over life insurance beneficiary designations, how New York courts address them, and the steps that can be taken to resolve such issues. Trief & Olk provides skilled legal guidance to help clients navigate and resolve complex life insurance beneficiary disputes.

Why Disputes Over Beneficiary Designations Happen

Life insurance beneficiary disputes often stem from disagreements about who should receive the payout from a policy. These disagreements may arise from family dynamics, errors in documentation, or questions about the policyholder’s intentions. One common source of dispute is when a policyholder makes a last-minute change to their beneficiary list before their death. For example, they might add or remove someone from the list. This can cause confusion, especially if the policyholder did not clearly communicate these changes to their family. In some cases, beneficiaries may argue that the policyholder was under pressure or lacked mental capacity when making these changes, leading to disputes about the validity of the new designation.

Ted Trief (Partner)

Life insurance attorney since 1976

Barbara Olk (Retired)

Life insurance attorney since 1976

Eyal Dror (Associate)

Life Insurance Attorney since 2007

 Disputes can also occur when a policyholder fails to update their beneficiary designation after major life events, such as divorce or remarriage. In these situations, an ex-spouse may remain listed as the beneficiary even though the policyholder may have intended for their new spouse or children to receive the benefits. In New York, this can lead to legal battles between family members. Another issue arises when there is conflicting information between the beneficiary designation on the life insurance policy and the policyholder’s will. While a will typically controls the distribution of assets, life insurance policies operate under separate rules, and the named beneficiary on the policy usually takes precedence over what is written in a will.

How New York Courts Handle Beneficiary Disputes

New York courts take a close look at the details of life insurance policies when disputes arise. The first step in resolving these disputes often involves reviewing the language of the life insurance contract and the beneficiary designation form. Courts in New York will attempt to determine the policyholder’s intent by analyzing the documents and any relevant evidence. If there are questions about the policyholder’s mental state or whether they were under undue influence when making changes to the beneficiary list, the court may consider testimony from family members, friends, or medical professionals. Evidence that suggests the policyholder was not acting freely or did not fully understand the changes they were making could lead to the court invalidating those changes.

Quote

We contacted Trief & Olk to help us with a life insurance issue and Shelly Friedland was the attorney assigned to our case. Before Shelly took our case she explained to us that the likelihood of our success without going to court was possible but not likely. Unfortunately we did not get the outcome we had hoped for but it was our decision to not move forward and have our case litigated. Shelly is very knowledgeable and was very straight-forward in her assessment of our case as we moved forward. She was very patient and thorough in answering our questions. She always responded in a timely manner and listened to our concerns. We would certainly recommend Shelly and would use her firm again in the future.”

- John Ramig

Quote

If there is any possibility of winning your life insurance case – this is the place to do it for you. They are efficient, honest and will achieve the best possible outcome.

Shelly Friedland worked on my case where a life insurance policy had lapsed and was even a few days beyond the grace period. Farmers had rejected my claim twice and was unwilling to take a second look. Shelly was able to get them to pay the entire claim without going to court, and the full amount was deposited in my account within a couple months. Highest recommendation.”

- Kathleen Brown

Quote

Trief & Olk is a superior law firm. Their attorneys and other legal professionals have a brilliant understanding of the law and the litigation process. They diligently perform their work in an efficient, strategic and cost-effective manner to ensure the best possible outcomes for their clients.

- Christopher Hughes

 New York law also addresses situations where a policyholder has failed to update their beneficiary designation after divorce. Under New York’s Estates, Powers, and Trusts Law, an ex-spouse is automatically removed as the beneficiary of a life insurance policy if the divorce was finalized after the policy was issued, unless the policyholder specifically took action to keep the ex-spouse as the beneficiary. This means that if a policyholder wanted their ex-spouse to remain the beneficiary after the divorce, they would need to file new paperwork with their insurance company. Another key factor the court considers is whether the beneficiary designation was properly completed and submitted. If there are any errors or missing information on the beneficiary form, the court may need to interpret the policyholder’s intent based on other evidence. In some cases, the court may even decide that the insurance proceeds should be split among multiple parties if there is a clear indication that the policyholder intended for more than one person to benefit from the policy.

Challenging Beneficiary Designations in New York

In New York, if someone believes that a beneficiary designation is incorrect or unfair, they may challenge it in court. Challenging a beneficiary designation can be a complicated legal process, as courts must weigh several factors to determine whether the designation should stand or be overturned.

Life Insurance Denial Statistics

20%

The annual average number of life insurance claims denied.

$50 Million

The yearly average dollar amount of claims denied by life insurance companies.

.2%

The number of claims appealed annually by consumers.

 One common challenge is based on the argument that the policyholder was not of sound mind when they made the designation or changed it. For example, if the policyholder was suffering from a medical condition that impaired their judgment, a beneficiary might argue that the designation was not valid. To succeed in this type of challenge, the person bringing the claim must provide evidence, such as medical records or witness statements, showing that the policyholder was not mentally capable of making a sound decision. Another challenge might be that the policyholder was coerced or under duress when they changed their beneficiary designation. In this case, the challenger would need to show that someone pressured the policyholder into making changes they would not have made otherwise. This could involve providing testimony or documents that demonstrate the policyholder’s true intentions before they were influenced by someone else. It is also possible to challenge a beneficiary designation on the grounds that it was not properly filed with the insurance company. If the paperwork was not completed or submitted according to the policy’s rules, the court may rule that the designation is invalid, and the benefits may go to the next closest heir.

Settlements & Verdicts

$3 Million Policy

William Penn Life Insurance

$1.2 Million Policy

Primerica

$1.5 Million Policy

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company

$1 Million Policy

Protective Life Insurance

$675,000 Settlement

Confidential Settlement

$4.3 Million Policy

State Farm, Primerica, Farmers, BrightHouse

Steps to Resolve Life Insurance Beneficiary Disputes

Resolving life insurance beneficiary disputes often requires legal action, but there are steps that can be taken to prevent these conflicts from escalating. Communication is one of the most important steps. Policyholders should communicate their intentions clearly to their family and beneficiaries. This helps avoid surprises and misunderstandings after their death. Additionally, policyholders should regularly review and update their life insurance beneficiary designations, especially after major life events such as marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child. Keeping beneficiary designations up-to-date helps prevent disputes about who should receive the life insurance proceeds. For those involved in a dispute, seeking legal guidance early in the process is crucial. A law firm with experience in life insurance disputes can help review the policy and beneficiary designation, gather evidence, and represent the parties in court. Without legal help, beneficiaries may find themselves struggling to navigate the complexities of the law.

The Importance of Legal Representation

Life insurance beneficiary disputes can be emotionally draining and financially significant. For families dealing with the loss of a loved one, the added stress of a legal battle over life insurance proceeds can be overwhelming. Having a knowledgeable guide can make a significant difference in how quickly and smoothly these disputes are resolved. Legal representation can help beneficiaries understand their rights, gather the necessary documents and evidence, and present a strong case in court. In many cases, having legal support can also lead to settlements without the need for a lengthy court process, allowing families to resolve their differences and move forward. For policyholders, working with a law firm can help ensure that their life insurance designations reflect their true intentions. By keeping beneficiary designations updated and clearly communicated, policyholders can reduce the chances of disputes after their death. If you are facing a life insurance beneficiary dispute or need help understanding your rights, Trief & Olk is here to provide the legal guidance you need. Our firm has extensive experience handling life insurance disputes in New York. We understand how complex and emotional these situations can be, and we are committed to helping you navigate them. Contact us today for a consultation, and let us help you protect your family’s future.