The Role of Intent in Massachusetts Life Insurance Misrepresentation Cases

Life insurance policies are crucial financial tools that provide peace of mind to families, ensuring they are financially protected after the death of a loved one. However, the process of obtaining a life insurance policy is not always straightforward. Massachusetts, like many states, has stringent laws governing life insurance contracts. One of the key factors that often comes up in disputes between policyholders and insurance companies is the issue of misrepresentation. Specifically, how does intent play a role in life insurance misrepresentation cases in Massachusetts?

What is Life Insurance Misrepresentation?

Misrepresentation in the context of life insurance refers to providing false or incomplete information during the application process. This can involve failing to disclose important medical conditions, engaging in fraudulent statements about lifestyle habits, or not fully answering questions on the insurance application. These omissions or errors can have serious consequences, especially if the insured individual dies shortly after obtaining the policy. When an insurance company finds that the applicant made a material misrepresentation, they often seek to void the policy or refuse to pay out the death benefit to the beneficiary. In Massachusetts, life insurance companies have the legal right to contest a claim based on misrepresentation. However, whether or not the misrepresentation was intentional is critical.

Intent and Its Importance in Misrepresentation Cases

In many life insurance misrepresentation cases, one of the central issues is whether the misrepresentation was made intentionally or accidentally. The key distinction is whether the applicant knowingly provided false information (intentional misrepresentation) or whether they made an honest mistake (unintentional misrepresentation). The implications of this distinction can drastically affect the outcome of the case.

Ted Trief (Partner)

Life insurance attorney since 1976

Barbara Olk (Retired)

Life insurance attorney since 1976

Eyal Dror (Associate)

Life Insurance Attorney since 2007

Massachusetts law holds that insurance companies may deny coverage or void a policy if an applicant intentionally provides false information with the knowledge that it will influence the decision of the insurer. However, if the misrepresentation was an honest mistake or was made in good faith, the case may be treated differently.

How Massachusetts Law Defines Intent

Under Massachusetts law, insurance companies can void a life insurance policy or deny a claim if they prove that the applicant made a material misrepresentation. This misrepresentation must be deliberate and relevant to the insurer’s decision-making process. To succeed in denying a claim on the grounds of misrepresentation, the insurance company must establish that the misrepresentation was intentional and not an unintentional error.

Quote

We contacted Trief & Olk to help us with a life insurance issue and Shelly Friedland was the attorney assigned to our case. Before Shelly took our case she explained to us that the likelihood of our success without going to court was possible but not likely. Unfortunately we did not get the outcome we had hoped for but it was our decision to not move forward and have our case litigated. Shelly is very knowledgeable and was very straight-forward in her assessment of our case as we moved forward. She was very patient and thorough in answering our questions. She always responded in a timely manner and listened to our concerns. We would certainly recommend Shelly and would use her firm again in the future.”

- John Ramig

Quote

If there is any possibility of winning your life insurance case – this is the place to do it for you. They are efficient, honest and will achieve the best possible outcome.

Shelly Friedland worked on my case where a life insurance policy had lapsed and was even a few days beyond the grace period. Farmers had rejected my claim twice and was unwilling to take a second look. Shelly was able to get them to pay the entire claim without going to court, and the full amount was deposited in my account within a couple months. Highest recommendation.”

- Kathleen Brown

Quote

Trief & Olk is a superior law firm. Their attorneys and other legal professionals have a brilliant understanding of the law and the litigation process. They diligently perform their work in an efficient, strategic and cost-effective manner to ensure the best possible outcomes for their clients.

- Christopher Hughes

Intentional misrepresentation occurs when the applicant knowingly provides false information to obtain a policy or to receive benefits they would not otherwise be entitled to. For example, if an applicant falsely states that they have never smoked or hides a history of a serious medical condition like heart disease, and the insurer can prove that this was done knowingly, the insurer may argue that the contract is void. The burden of proof lies with the insurance company. They must provide clear and convincing evidence that the applicant had the intent to deceive the company. If the insurer fails to meet this burden, the case may still proceed in favor of the policyholder or their beneficiaries.

Unintentional Misrepresentation and Its Consequences

Not all misrepresentations are intentional. Many policyholders might answer questions on their life insurance applications incorrectly due to a lack of understanding or forgetfulness. Massachusetts courts recognize that not all errors are intentional, and insurers may be required to provide proof that the misrepresentation was material and that it was made with the intent to deceive. For instance, a policyholder might accidentally omit a minor medical condition or fail to disclose a previous hospital visit because they didn’t think it was relevant. In these cases, the insurance company will have to prove that the omission was intentional, and if it is determined to be an honest mistake, the insurer may be required to pay the claim.

The Role of the “Incontestability Clause” in Massachusetts

In Massachusetts, life insurance policies are often subject to an incontestability clause. This clause limits the time in which an insurance company can contest the validity of a policy due to misrepresentation. Generally, Massachusetts law requires that an insurer cannot contest a policy for misrepresentation after two years from the policy’s issue date. If a misrepresentation is discovered after this time period, it becomes much harder for the insurer to deny the claim, unless fraud can be proven. This is a significant protection for policyholders, ensuring that the insurance company cannot arbitrarily void a policy after a long period has passed.

Settlements & Verdicts

$3 Million Policy

William Penn Life Insurance

$1.2 Million Policy

Primerica

$1.5 Million Policy

Metropolitan Life Insurance Company

$1 Million Policy

Protective Life Insurance

$675,000 Settlement

Confidential Settlement

$4.3 Million Policy

State Farm, Primerica, Farmers, BrightHouse

The Impact of Intent on Insurance Claims

The role of intent in Massachusetts life insurance misrepresentation cases can determine whether a claim is paid out or whether a policy is voided. If an insurer can prove that the applicant intentionally made false statements to gain a benefit, the claim may be denied outright. On the other hand, if the insurer cannot prove intent, the policyholder’s beneficiaries may still be entitled to the death benefit. In cases where unintentional misrepresentation occurs, the court may focus on the materiality of the false statement. Was the misrepresentation significant enough to influence the insurer’s decision to issue the policy? If not, the insurer might still be required to pay the claim.

What Should Policyholders Do in the Event of a Misrepresentation Dispute?

If you are facing a life insurance dispute in Massachusetts involving alleged misrepresentation, it’s important to seek legal counsel immediately. A skilled attorney can help you understand whether the misrepresentation was intentional and how Massachusetts law applies to your case. An attorney will work to ensure that your rights are protected and help you gather evidence to demonstrate that any misrepresentations made were either unintentional or insignificant. If you believe that the insurer is unfairly denying your claim, legal professionals can provide the guidance needed to challenge the insurer’s decision in court. Life insurance misrepresentation cases in Massachusetts can be complex, especially when the issue of intent arises. The outcome of a case can depend on whether the misrepresentation was made intentionally or by mistake. While insurance companies may have grounds to deny a claim based on intentional misrepresentation, proving intent can be difficult. If you are dealing with a life insurance misrepresentation dispute, it’s essential to understand your rights under Massachusetts law. Legal guidance can help ensure that your case is handled properly, and that justice is served for both the policyholder and their beneficiaries. If you’re facing a life insurance misrepresentation case in Massachusetts, don’t navigate this complex legal terrain alone. Contact our experienced team at Trief & Olk to discuss your situation and ensure that your interests are protected. Our team is committed to helping you resolve your case fairly and efficiently.

To learn more about this subject click here: Material Misrepresentation in New York Life Insurance Policies: Key Facts You Should Know